Fidelity battles IRS in court over coal tax credits




Fidelity battles IRS in court over coal tax credits


By Tim McLaughlin

BOSTON (Reuters) - Fidelity Investments' courtroom battle with the IRS over disallowed tax credits drew to a close on Tuesday when lawyers clashed over whether the mutual fund giant was a bonafide partner in the production of chemically treated coal.

U.S. Tax Court Judge David Gustafson said he may deliver his decision in the case as early as Wednesday. The outcome of the trial is being closely watched by Wall Street firms and other U.S. corporations because the production of chemically treated, or refined coal, generates more than $1 billion a year in tax credits. Beneficiaries of the tax credit program include Goldman Sachs Group Inc (N:GS), JPMorgan Chase & Co (N:JPM) and pharmaceutical company Mylan NV (O:MYL), to name a few.

Boston-based Fidelity invested in the production of refined coal at three South Carolina power plants to qualify for tax credits that could total up to $330 million over 10 years. The coal is treated with chemicals to cut mercury and smog pollution.

The U.S. Internal Revenue Service, however, disallowed millions of dollars in tax credits and claimed losses reported by a Fidelity-led partnership in 2011 and 2012. The IRS says the partnership had little downside risk and was only created to "facilitate the prohibited transaction of monetizing refined coal tax credits."

But Brian Kittle, in his closing arguments on Tuesday in U.S. Tax Court in Boston, argued Fidelity and its partners were bonafide and faced plenty of downside in the form of financial, environmental and reputational risk from their investment.

"Nobody wants to be associated with coal," Kittle told Judge Gustafson. Kittle added that Fidelity is seen as a trusted adviser and saw the production of refined coal as an opportunity to earn tax credits and cut pollution.

But the refined coal partnership that also included insurance broker Arthur J. Gallagher & Co (N:AJG) and Schneider Electric SE (PA:SCHN) encountered setbacks.

During the two-week trial, Kittle and other lawyers detailed environmental and operational problems as evidence that the partnership was engaged in an investment with plenty of risk potential.

In May 2012, for example, chemicals used to treat coal at the Cross Generating Station in Pineville, South Carolina caused an elevated level of carcinogenic trihalomethanes in the Santee Cooper-Lake Moultrie Public Water System. The refined coal operation at Cross was shut down for three years, limiting the partnership's tax credits.





Related News

UK posts small budget surplus as government spending rises before Brexit
Today, 09:15
LONDON, Reuters) - Britain posted a smaller-than-expected budget surplus in July as government expenditure rose, underlining budget constraints on new Prime Minister Boris Johnson as he promises to boost spending ahead of Brexit. The surplus,
DHL stops deliveries for Amazon Fresh in Germany
Today, 09:12
BERLIN (Reuters) - Deutsche Post DHL (DE:DPWGn) will no longer deliver fresh food in Germany for Amazon (O:AMZN) as demand for the service launched in 2017 has been disappointing, a spokeswoman said on Wednesday. Selling food is a key part of the
Hong Kong protests spread to subway as bank warns of economic fallout
Today, 09:09
By Felix Tam and Alun John HONG KONG (Reuters) - A major bank warned on Wednesday that weeks of protests in Hong Kong could hit the economies of the Chinese-ruled city and mainland China itself as demonstrators prepared a sit-in at a subway and site
Porsche invests in Israeli road visibility startup TriEye
Today, 09:06
TEL AVIV (Reuters) - Israel's TriEye, whose short-wave-infra-red sensing technology enables vision in adverse weather and night-time conditions, has expanded its funding round to $19 million with an investment from German sports car
Exclusive: China's Tianjin government orders Bohai Steel restructuring start by September: sources
Today, 09:03
By Shu Zhang and Muyu Xu SINGAPORE/BEIJING (Reuters) - The government of the Chinese city of Tianjin, the only shareholder of bankrupt Bohai Steel Group Ltd, is demanding that Bohai's creditors and strategic investor implement a bankruptcy



Latest News
UK posts small budget surplus as government spending rises before Brexit
21.08.2019 09:15
LONDON, Reuters) - Britain posted a smaller-than-expected budget surplus in July as government expenditure rose, underlining budget constraints on new Prime Minister Boris Johnson as he promises to boost spending ahead of Brexit. The surplus, excluding state-owned banks, stood at 1.319 billion pounds, compared with 3.562 billion pounds in July
Read more
DHL stops deliveries for Amazon Fresh in Germany
21.08.2019 09:12
BERLIN (Reuters) - Deutsche Post DHL (DE:DPWGn) will no longer deliver fresh food in Germany for Amazon (O:AMZN) as demand for the service launched in 2017 has been disappointing, a spokeswoman said on Wednesday. Selling food is a key part of the strategy of the world's top online retailer, especially since it bought the U.S. chain Whole
Read more
Hong Kong protests spread to subway as bank warns of economic fallout
21.08.2019 09:09
By Felix Tam and Alun John HONG KONG (Reuters) - A major bank warned on Wednesday that weeks of protests in Hong Kong could hit the economies of the Chinese-ruled city and mainland China itself as demonstrators prepared a sit-in at a subway and site of a mid-summer mob attack. Hong Kong-based Bank of East Asia Ltd (BEA) posted a 75% slump in
Read more
Porsche invests in Israeli road visibility startup TriEye
21.08.2019 09:06
TEL AVIV (Reuters) - Israel's TriEye, whose short-wave-infra-red sensing technology enables vision in adverse weather and night-time conditions, has expanded its funding round to $19 million with an investment from German sports car manufacturer Porsche (DE:PSHG_p). The amount invested by Porsche was not disclosed. TriEye said on Wednesday
Read more
Exclusive: China's Tianjin government orders Bohai Steel restructuring start by September: sources
21.08.2019 09:03
By Shu Zhang and Muyu Xu SINGAPORE/BEIJING (Reuters) - The government of the Chinese city of Tianjin, the only shareholder of bankrupt Bohai Steel Group Ltd, is demanding that Bohai's creditors and strategic investor implement a bankruptcy restructuring plan by the end of September, two creditor sources with direct knowledge of the matter
Read more