EPA ignores health benefits of coal rule it plans to weaken: economists




EPA ignores health benefits of coal rule it plans to weaken: economists


By Timothy Gardner

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - A U.S. Environmental Protection Agency proposal to weaken a rule on coal plant pollution fails to consider billions of dollars in health benefits for Americans, economists from universities including Harvard and Yale said on Wednesday.

The six economists said the proposal to change the rule on mercury emissions from coal-fired power plants ignores an Obama-era estimate that it would slash U.S. healthcare bills by $33 billion to $90 billion per year. The rule would save billions of dollars in healthcare costs because it requires plants to not only cut emissions of mercury, but also fine particulates that cause heart and lung illnesses, they said.

But the Trump administration, which has aimed to slash regulations governing fossil fuel production, last year proposed revising the mercury rule while scrapping its estimate of the cost savings from reductions in emissions of fine particulates. The administration is expected to throw out an Obama administration finding that it is "appropriate and necessary" to regulate power plant emissions when it finalizes the proposal in coming weeks.

"Instead of weighing all the costs against all the benefits, the EPA is cherry picking," said Yale University's Matthew Kotchen, who released a report on the agency's proposal with the other economists. "They pulled the biggest public health benefit off the scale."

The U.S. coal industry has suffered under President Donald Trump despite his policy to ease regulations, due to a glut of cheap natural gas and falling costs for wind and solar power.

Several of the authors of the report, including Kotchen, were on the EPA's Environmental Economics Advisory Committee that was part of the agency's independent science advisory board for 25 years. The EPA's Science Advisory Board unanimously dissolved the economics committee last year, after the Trump administration reduced the number of academic scientists on the board. The authors are now on the External Environmental Economics Advisory Committee, an independent group that says it provides nonpartisan advice on EPA programs.

The Obama administration had estimated that the mercury rule would cost utilities up to $9.6 billion annually but that would be outweighed by the cuts in healthcare bills.

The EPA under Trump estimated that the rule would only save up to $6 million annually because it removed the benefits from cuts in fine particulates.

An EPA spokeswoman said the agency was not doing away with the mercury rule, but "providing regulatory certainty by transparently and accurately taking account of both costs and benefits."

The economists said that if the final rule scraps the Obama-era finding it will do away with its original justification, making it vulnerable to future lawsuits that could eventually kill the rule and make it harder to issue broad new emissions regulations.





Related News

NFL notebook: Giants officially give Manning starting nod
Today, 02:09
Eli Manning will start at quarterback for the New York Giants against the Philadelphia Eagles on Monday night in place of rookie Daniel Jones, who has been ruled out with a high-ankle sprain, the team announced Saturday. Manning, 38, has not started
North Korea carries out 'very significant' test at satellite launch site: KCNA
Today, 02:06
SEOUL (Reuters) - North Korea has carried out a "very significant" test at its Sohae satellite launch site, state media KCNA reported on Sunday, a rocket testing ground that U.S. officials once said North Korea had promised to close. The
Australian firefighters try to control bushfires ahead of hot days
Today, 02:03
By Lidia Kelly MELBOURNE (Reuters) - Firefighters in eastern Australia used easing weather conditions on Sunday to bring bushfires under control ahead of forecast of soaring temperatures for next week. There were 96 fires burning in New South Wales,
Hong Kong gears up for mass rally as government appeals for calm
Today, 01:03
HONG KONG (Reuters) - Hong Kong was gearing up for a mass rally on Sunday that is expected to gauge support for pro-democracy demonstrations in the Chinese-ruled city as the government appealed to people to express their views peacefully. Police
Shooting near Mexico's presidential residence leaves four dead - local media
Today, 00:06
MEXICO CITY (Reuters) - A shooting on Saturday near Mexico's National Palace, the president's residence in the capital's historic downtown, has left four people dead and two people injured, Foro TV reported. Mexican President Andres



Latest News
NFL notebook: Giants officially give Manning starting nod
08.12.2019 02:09
Eli Manning will start at quarterback for the New York Giants against the Philadelphia Eagles on Monday night in place of rookie Daniel Jones, who has been ruled out with a high-ankle sprain, the team announced Saturday. Manning, 38, has not started since Week 2. He passed for 556 yards, two touchdowns and two interceptions before the Giants
Read more
North Korea carries out 'very significant' test at satellite launch site: KCNA
08.12.2019 02:06
SEOUL (Reuters) - North Korea has carried out a "very significant" test at its Sohae satellite launch site, state media KCNA reported on Sunday, a rocket testing ground that U.S. officials once said North Korea had promised to close. The KCNA report did not specify what was tested, but the site has previously been used to launch rockets
Read more
Australian firefighters try to control bushfires ahead of hot days
08.12.2019 02:03
By Lidia Kelly MELBOURNE (Reuters) - Firefighters in eastern Australia used easing weather conditions on Sunday to bring bushfires under control ahead of forecast of soaring temperatures for next week. There were 96 fires burning in New South Wales, home to Australia's largest city of Sydney, with only about a half contained and more than
Read more
Hong Kong gears up for mass rally as government appeals for calm
08.12.2019 01:03
HONG KONG (Reuters) - Hong Kong was gearing up for a mass rally on Sunday that is expected to gauge support for pro-democracy demonstrations in the Chinese-ruled city as the government appealed to people to express their views peacefully. Police gave the green light to Civil Human Rights Front (CHRF) - organizer of largely peaceful million-strong
Read more
Shooting near Mexico's presidential residence leaves four dead - local media
08.12.2019 00:06
MEXICO CITY (Reuters) - A shooting on Saturday near Mexico's National Palace, the president's residence in the capital's historic downtown, has left four people dead and two people injured, Foro TV reported. Mexican President Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador was traveling on Saturday.
Read more